Car Accident Rate Manual vs. Automatic: Is There a Difference?
November 21, 2023
Categories:
When it comes to driving, one of the choices we make is the type of transmission in our cars - manual or automatic. But have you ever wondered if this choice influences the likelihood of being involved in a car accident? Let’s take a look at what the figures say.
Before we take a look into accident rates, let's quickly recap the difference between manual and automatic transmissions. It’s simple, really: a manual car requires the driver to manually shift gears using a clutch pedal and gear stick, while an automatic car does this for you, allowing you to focus more on steering, braking, and accelerating.
Naturally, there’s more to accident rates than the type of transmission used: instead, what often instead counts is how we - as drivers - use them:
Firstly, a driver’s experience and comfort with their vehicle’s transmission can significantly impact their driving behaviour: manual transmission drivers tend to be perceived as more engaged with the driving process, while automatic transmissions can sometimes lead to a more relaxed driving style.
Cars with automatic transmissions often come with advanced safety features and assistive technology, and these features can contribute to reducing the likelihood of accidents.
Consider how transmission types might handle different driving conditions, such as city traffic or icy roads: the ease of driving an automatic in stop-start traffic, for example, might affect driver fatigue and attentiveness.
So, what does the UK data have to say about car accidents? In what might come as a surprise to some drivers, there is currently no study in the UK linking the transmission of a vehicle and the likelihood of being in an accident.
That being said, a 2008 study from Japan concluded that accident rates were higher - by almost twice as much - for automatic vehicles, except for head-on collisions and fatal crashes. Among fatal accidents, the accident rates for both types of vehicles are roughly the same
So, what does this study tell us about how transmission can influence safety in the UK? In short, there’s no greater chance of being in a fatal accident or head-on collision if you drive an automatic or a manual. However, mild and moderate accidents do tend to be higher amongst those driving automatic cars, which ultimately comes down to driver behaviour we discussed above.
Ultimately, when it comes down to comparing car accident rates between manual and automatic cars, it's clear that various factors come into play: from experience to the built-in safety features of the car, each aspect contributes to the overall picture of road safety. But what counts the most? In almost every case, the driver’s behaviour on the road.
So, whether you prefer manual or automatic, remember that safe driving practices, heightened awareness of your surroundings, and understanding your vehicle's capabilities are absolutely imperative when it comes to preventing accidents. And if you do find yourself in an accident, regardless of your car's transmission, seeking expert advice for car accident claims can provide the necessary support and guidance to get you through what can be a long and complicated legal process.
Safety isn't solely dependent on the type of transmission but rather a combination of factors including driver experience, vehicle safety features, and driving conditions. Both manual and automatic cars have their own advantages and challenges in terms of safety; the key is to remain alert at all times when driving.
Many argue that driving a manual car requires more engagement as it involves actively shifting gears, which might enhance focus and attentiveness. However, this can vary greatly depending on the driver’s skill and comfort with manual transmission.
Generally, newer automatic cars tend to incorporate more advanced safety features and driver aids, which can contribute to reducing accident risks. However, this can also depend on the car’s make, model, and year.
If you’re considering a switch for safety reasons, it’s essential to evaluate all aspects, including the safety features offered, your comfort and experience with each transmission type, and how each fits your driving environment. If you’re easily distracted on the road, a manual stick might be best for you.
Insurance rates can be influenced by various factors, including the car's safety features and accident risk profile. Transmission type might play a role but is typically not the primary factor when it comes to determining insurance costs.
